audio transcript · Dreams & Visions

Dream Psychology, Part 2 of 4

Transcriptions from live audio lectures across many years of Dr. Baker’s teaching. Original recordings are on douglasbaker.org and at douglasbakerbooks.com/audiolectures.

Dream Psychology, Part 2 of 4

We continue then with our observations on the dream psychology, generally as presented by Jung, contrasted with Freud, and with correlations to the observations of esoteric science. We were considering how, as spirituality advances, the self becomes almost anthropomorphic, and may even begin to intervene in the dream life. We consider, under that heading, that the self may attempt to illuminate the ego over its interpretation of symbols coming from the unconscious.

We also pointed out that the self might even introduce a factor of trauma, or of drama, in a dream so that the ego can remember it, and therefore to act upon it. We have begun to understand also that the most significant dream of the evening tends to be the waking event, and that it is the waking dream that will tend to reflect the central theme, the nucleus, of the train of dream events. So we have reached this consideration of the self's intervention in the dream life.

The self may seek to communicate with the ego consciously in the dream life. Now, we have learnt about an ego-self axis, but there has not been so far the suggestion that the self might try and communicate with the ego directly, and as one anthropomorphic entity to another. It might be that the self may induce the ego to make an answer in a dream, or that the ego takes a voluntary part in the dream vision, perhaps answering the master in the course of events, or that the ego might be induced to question the self.

When I said master a moment ago, I deliberately put that in so as to bring in the esoteric factor, which implies that the self is the master. You are beginning to understand now what that meaning is, that the self is the master. There are many explanations of it, but this is another one.

Also, the dream may be such that the outer consciousness, the waking part of life, or the object of life, might begin to intrude into the dream meaningfully. The dream might be so constructed or so permitted by the self that the outside events, events going on in the room of the sleeper, might begin to intrude and to contribute to the effects of the dream. The outer world's manifestations may replace the symbols of the dream.

Somebody in the dream may be calling out the name of Bob, Bob, and that may combine momentarily with the sound of a dog barking outside, Bob, Bob, Bob. And the two together blend to produce some meaningful aspect in the dream. The dream draws on the most recent and relevant symbols appropriated from the consciousness of the previous day.

You'll say, well, what does the dream content mainly contain? And the answer would be that the most recent symbols, experiences, from the previous day will be used. And it will often strike you that some matter that you haven't been able to deal with at the moment consciously, and then pushed aside, comes up in your dream life. Or some event of the day shows up in the dream that night.

So the dream would tend to draw on the most recent and relevant symbols. Jung confirmed that dreams could even have moral tendencies, and even spiritual leanings. So he was generally concerned with individuals who were not esoteric, but under stress frequently, often neurotic, often psychotic.

And he confirmed that in that type of patient, dreams might even have spiritual leanings. Well, we say this is true of highly developed individuals, but more so, there are definite spiritual leanings, and definitely the dream becomes, as it were, the province of communication between the ego and self. So the axis not only becomes, the ego-self axis not only becomes established, but a dialogue is established, and the dialogue eventually takes place between two anthropomorphic beings, the ego and the self, anthropomorphic meaning human-shaped.

The more energy-laden the dream or the vision we have already seen, the more valid are its implications in terms of consciousness. The more vivid the dream, the more valid its expressions tend to be in the waking consciousness. What we're actually talking about here is a link, in fact, between the self and the ego.

The self and the ego. That symbol straightaway is meaningful to all esoteric students in the class who have taken any of the diplomas. This leads on to the concept of Jung's attitude on the distortion of dreams, the distortion of dreams.

And Freud and Jung met in headlong collision on this matter of the distortion of dreams. They both had completely different views about the matter. On the one hand, it was Freud who proposed that the reason why we couldn't understand a dream was that it had been censored.

The dream material was the result of censoring by the unconscious. So Freud asserted that our consciousness places a censor in our dreams. There are certain things that we don't like, and therefore we possess a censor that doesn't allow these unpleasant things to enter our awareness.

Freud asserted that this censor stops certain matters that are painful to us from getting through, and that with other matters, the censor masked them, couldn't stop them coming through into consciousness, and so the censor would mask them and generally inhibit our comprehension of the meaning of the dream if it was painful to us. Jung supported him initially until about 1916, and then he ignored the concept of the censor after that. Freud had said that the censor represented a sort of resistance of the consciousness against some complex.

Some complex, some psychological complex existed, and that the censor resisted against it, and wouldn't allow the thoughts concerning that complex to pass by into consciousness until those thoughts were so disguised that the dreamer was unable to recognize them. They would have to get through eventually, but the censor would distort the material so that the consciousness wouldn't recognize it. So, if we pause a moment, we've got to insert, as it were, a censor in relation to the ego.

There is the conscious ego. There is the unconscious. There is the unconscious of the superego.

And so there is a sort of an antechamber which is inhabited by a censor that won't allow unpleasant matters to enter the ego consciousness without first of all reviewing them and altering them if they are unpalatable to the ego consciousness. And the more fragile the ego, one assumes, the more fragile the ego, the more censored will be the material presented to it. If it is material, it can shatter the ego, then the censorship and the distortion will be accordingly far more imposed.

Using a metaphor, Freud said the consciousness was like an audience chamber with an empty room. So here is the audience chamber of the ego, which is consciousness, the audience chamber of the ego, and here is the antechamber, wherever material from the unconscious manifests itself for presentation in the audience chamber of the ego, there was present a censor. And in this empty room, which is really part of the unconscious, ideas are milling around, they're milling around inside the empty room.

You want to make that one empty room and you'll have to put your superego there and your head there, with a consciousness here, with a consciousness there, and an antechamber here. And they're all seeking audience, all seeking entry into the audience chamber. But at the doorway to the audience chamber, that's the doorway, at the doorway to the audience chamber there stands the censor.

And the censor prevents all ideas from entering the main chamber, or consciousness, except the most harmless ones. Only the most harmless ideas are allowed into the ego's consciousness. Once these ideas get in to the audience chamber, they still have to gain the attention of the ego.

Don't forget the ego is a point of consciousness in the ego field. And so the ideas, harmless, once they get in there, they still have to clamor for attention of the ego, which may ignore them. The ego may ignore them, even though they're brought into the consciousness.

Some idea may get past the censor, some ideas may get past the censor if they're disguised, if they're disguised. If they are blatant and openly presented, the censor will stop them altogether. But so powerful are they, so insidious may they be, that they will adopt a disguise and get past the censor.

Especially if the censor is asleep. If the censor's attention is distracted or the censor is asleep. Then, as in the case of dreams, they tend to get through, partly disguised maybe.

They also get through in a psychosis, in a psychosis, where the element of the unreal becomes a part of the consciousness. In the psychotic individual, these ideas may get through, and especially in psychotic people, as in schizophrenia, where there's a lot of mobile energy floating around. Energy which we sometimes experience in our personalities is the ability to dramatize things.

Well, the schizophrenic has a lot of this energy floating around, and if some of it is grabbed by the idea, it may overpower the censor. So this rough account of Freud's concept shows that he gave an explanation for the distortion of the dreams. Why dreams were often garbled and appeared to be nonsense, clothed in extraordinary symbols.

Jung couldn't accept this. After 1916, Jung couldn't accept this. He couldn't accept that there was some sort of little hobgoblin inside of us which deliberately concealed our wishes and ideas, a crafty, cunning little mannequin that falsified the truth.

So they were at loggerheads over this. Both Freud and Jung, however, found that dreams were expressed most frequently as parables and as similes. As parables and as similes.

It was rare, very rare, and this is true for all of us, that a dream will express itself exactly as the truth. Exactly as the truth. So as a disciple, we have to have practice in the use of parables and in the use of substitutes or similes.

And we have good training for this in dealing with arities and in establishing meditational procedures. We get good experience of all this. So now we begin to understand why, according to both Freud and Jung, dream symbols can convey such fantastic and bizarre and often ridiculous experiences.

They are similes or parables for the real thing. And both agreed on that. Freud, from his point of view, saw all this lack of clarity about the dream as being an attempt to disguise the true meaning of the dream from the dreamer.

Jung believed that the lack of clarity, on the other hand, indicated the essence of the root or background processes from which the dream sprang. Jung was not happy with Freud's explanation and regarded the non-clarity of the dream as existing because it was expressing the root derivation of the dream that I discussed yesterday. It was describing, in part as well, the root derivation of the dream.

It was, in fact, reflecting elements of the collective unconscious of the family, of the tribe, of the race, and even of mankind itself. Jung believed that the dream was abstruse and lacking in clarity because this is the true nature of things in the unconscious. The dream is lacking in clarity, is full of symbol, is non-objective, because this is what the collective unconscious is like.

And so the dream is not a distortion, it is merely reflecting what exists in the unconscious. Jung would not accept that the unconscious from which the dream sprang knows no other aim than the fulfillment of wishes. This is what Freud believed, that the unconscious was trying to substitute what we were wishing for.

And when we couldn't get it in our ordinary personality lives, the dream gave us what we wished for. That the unconscious supplied what was missing from our personality lives that we desired most. But Jung could not accept that.

He said that the view that dreams are merely the imaginary fulfillments of repressed wishes is hopelessly out of date. There are, it is true, dreams which manifestly do represent wishes or fears. But what about all the other things in dreams? Dreams may contain ineluctable or inescapable truths, philosophical pronouncements.

They may contain illusions, wild fantasies, memories, plans, anticipations, irrational experiences, and even telepathic visions, and heaven knows what besides. One thing we ought never to forget, almost half our life has passed in a more or less unconscious state. That was Jung from the practical use of dream analysis.

So he would not accept that dreams merely gave us what we were wishing for and couldn't experience ordinary waking consciousness. He couldn't agree with Freud that during the night all the slime of objectionable and inferior contents, incestuous wishes, and even all evil thoughts such as hatred and egotism and death wishes attempted to find their way into the consciousness, which was the Freud concept, that when we relaxed, when we went to sleep at night, all the objectionable and inferior contents of our unconscious, all our repressed wishes and evil thoughts reared their ugly heads in the dream during the night. Instead, Jung said that the dream was a self-portrait.

The dream was a self-portrait. It was a portrayal of the inner situation of the dreamer. It was a portrayal of the inner situation of the dreamer.

To that we would add that the inner situation of the dreamer would take into account many facts, calming facts, memories of previous lives, the spiritual status of the individual, the proximity of the egoic lotus to its personality, and so on. Freud's biological approach to dreams led him to believe that dreams protected the sleep life and veiled the feelings or emotions. Freud said that when we went to sleep, dreams were an attempt to protect us from being constantly awakened.

And so our awfulest feelings and emotions, which would keep us awake indefinitely, were veiled, and the way that they were veiled to us but still presented to us was by dreams. And so Freud said that the dream mechanism was a protective mechanism. It protected the physiological or biological mechanism of sleep which we desperately needed.

And so much of Freud's stuff had the element of truth about it. To this day, especially so at this time, it is generally now accepted in psychological circles that the dream life is important to man and that it does protect him in some respects. But as a contradiction to this, it was noted, frequently observed, that there was a build-up of emotion.

Far from the emotion being hidden out of the way, brushed under the carpet, the dream produced a build-up of emotion and affect. And that the emotions frequently awakened the dreamer. So this was a contradiction of Freud.

That the dreams, far from concealing unpalatable emotions which would keep us awake, the dream in fact awakened us because of its emotional content. Jung, in contrast, emphasized the psychological effect of dreams. Jung emphasized the psychological effect of dreams.

Not the biological, but the psychological. He noted that suppression of an emotion in a dream could impede the development of the psyche. That if the emotional content of the dream was inhibited, not expressed, then the development of the psyche could be impeded.

The rounding out, if you like, as we call it in esoteric terms, of the psyche. He thought that heavily emphasized emotions and dreams could be life-stimulating. He really believed that dreams had such emotional qualities about them, energy-bearing qualities, that these energies could flow into the life, into the ego and stimulate the life-forces.

And that dreams would have such energies as they could energize and stimulate conscious orientation. In other words, dreams could provide an inward-directing influence that the conscious personality would eventually follow. So strong would be the trend of the emotional content of a dream that, although it was still unconscious, the ego would be led in that direction.

The ego would be led in that direction by the streams of emotion coming into the consciousness. In history, of course, we frequently have this happening, that bad dreams were used as a sort of augury of what was to follow. In Julius Caesar, the play Julius Caesar, the bad dreams plague Caesar the night before he is assassinated.

There is an ominous content in them, and he relates them to his wife and to his friends. The emotional foreboding of his dreams leads, as it were, him towards a confirmation of their worst implications, and that is the assassination. So Jung was saying that the dream emotional content somehow affected the direction of the ego during the day, or in the days that lay ahead of the dream.

The ego was affected in some way. Jung was quite outright in saying that dreams had a beneficial effect on sleep. He thought that the sleep was more restful, more regenerating of the ego, and that they were very good for the stability of the ego, and that has been confirmed in recent years.

Jung said that the psyche benefited if a meaning to the dream symbols was accepted by the dreamer. So we have a form of therapy emerging here. That if you could interpret the dream symbols for an individual so that he accepted this explanation, that the psyche of that individual benefited from it.

We employ this method in our own group here, in our own ashram. A method of therapy that we use. If you comprehended the meaning and contents of your dream symbols, you, the psyche, benefited from it.

We encourage in our group the free discussion of dream experiences. And everyone is encouraged to offer their explanation for the dream symbols being described by somebody in the group. And it can quite often be that some individual will supply an explanation for your dream which satisfies you.

The Red Indians would go to great extent, some of the tribes, to satisfy their dreams, to satisfy their dream symbols. They took it to the opposite extreme. The whole tribe would assist an individual to live out his dream.

If he had a vivid dream of hewing a pathway through a dense piece of forest in the proximity of the tribe, he would relate his dream and all the members of the tribe would assist him in hewing this pathway through the forest, which would in fact implement the dream itself. And this had some psychotherapeutic and even religious implications to the person who had dreamed it, because his dream had come true. It was being expressed.

And all members of the tribe might assist him. Now we come to the compensating function of dreams, the compensating function of dreams. We talked a little earlier about Emerson's observations on how everything in life is compensated for.

And sometimes we might feel that the experiences of our personalities, of our egos, are not being compensated for. And this would be especially true if people don't dream. The compensations that should come in the dream life, or that they don't remember these compensations, affects the balance of their psyche.

Freud had said that wish fulfillment and dreams compensated the psyche and appeased it for its failures. If you couldn't get in the outside world, if you couldn't satisfy your drives in the outside world, then your wishes, which were unfulfilled, would be fulfilled by the dream. And this would tend to appease you or appease the ego for its failures.

Jung showed that in psychotics and psychopaths, their hallucinations and sensory delusions were frequently compensating them for some factor in their personality. Jung believed that the delusions of the schizophrenic were helping him to compensate for difficulties in his ego life, in his personality life. One could say that the function of the unconscious in mental disturbances is essentially compensation of the conscious contents.

Those were Jung's observations. Jung soon found that compensation was not confined to the mentally ill. It was a law governing human consciousness, that all conscious acts in a waking life, experience of an ego, were compensated for by unconscious experiences.

All extreme conscious tendencies are softened and toned down through a counter-impulse in the unconscious. And if the conscious tendency was a very emphasized one, there would be a corresponding reflection in the dream life. We could leave the realm of psychology and go into poetry, and in the poetry of Gerard Manley Hopkins, there is recognition of just this fact, that if something strikes you, like the success of a bird flying against a high wind, and this caught your fancy, there would be immediately an in-stress of in-scape, he called it, an in-stress of in-scape.

And if it was the poet, who was extremely sensitive, he wouldn't have to have it in a dream life, but it would be a subjective experience. It would be an inner experience. And in discipleship, this is what we look for.

We don't look so much for dreams, but we look for the inner counterpart of our outward experiences. We don't expect to find them only in dreams, these inner counterparts. We expect to find them in waking consciousness, because we become more sensitive.

And before we became disciples, we were less sensitive, and the inner responses to these outer experiences were lost, were hidden from us. But now we do have them. And a poet like Gerard Manley Hopkins had them.

He saw this bird, the wind of a fighting, the high wind, and as I said, he took the image and buckled it to the heart, buckled it to his breast, and said, And the light that bursts from thee, the self, then, a thousand times told lovelier. He sees this magnificent achievement of the bird, standing on the cliffs, looking out over the sea, he sees the falcon beating the wind, and he takes this image to himself, and buckles it to his heart, where he believes the Christ lives, we call it the self, And the light that bursts from thee, then, a thousand times told lovelier. O my Chevalier.

Then he ends the poem by saying, No wonder of it, the sheer plot makes ploughed down sillion shine, and blue bleak embers fall, gall themselves, and gash gold vermillion. The blue bleak embers of the fire, the aridity of a person's life, may yet produce an inward flashing. So looking at the fire, the blue bleak embers suddenly fall, they're unproductive of light, unproductive of heat, they are sterile, like a person's personality, but something happens to jar the great, the coals hit each other, and they gash gold vermillion.

So he saw that in our lives, where there was stress, there would be an inner flaming up of something. Or as the plough's sheer fought its way, or as dragged through the clay, the wet clay, the harshness of this act of pulling the blade through the clay, as we sometimes pull our egos through each day's activity, nevertheless, that as the knife hits the clay, the clay peels away and gives off a beautiful sheen. Sheer plot makes ploughed-down sillion shine.

And this is what Jung was trying to say, that every utter experience of the ego has this inner compensatory mechanism from the unconscious. Now, these observations that I have extracted for you are all useful and meaningful. You should analyze them in your spiritual diaries and try and refer to them when you are faced with personality problems and issues.

Search for the compensatory mechanism. And when you search for a thing, you know what you're looking for. It's that we don't know what we're looking for, that we have such poor results from our subjective life.

If we knew what we were looking for, we would be able to find that in the unconscious or in the dreamland. This compensatory action proved Jung's most important teaching. It was his most important teaching.

That there is compensation in the subjective life for what occurs in the objective life. That there is an interplay, in fact, between the unconscious and the conscious. And the interplay between the two systems, according to Jung, is meaningful.

Is meaningful. In the esoteric, we say just this, that when we subject ourselves to stress outwardly, there are inner responses. The inner responses are meaningful.

The inner responses are meaningful because they represent the opening of the petals of the egoic lotus. The opening of the petals of the egoic lotus. And part of our work in this group will be to relate some of the events of the ego as it lives its life out to what petals are stirred in the egoic lotus as part of the subjective response of the individual.

We know that confrontation with color produces inward response of the petals. Colorful experiences. Confrontation with compassionate experiences.

Confrontation with intuitive experiences. Confrontation with sound. Especially in music.

Confrontation with magnetic experiences. Especially that form of magnetism which the esotericists call fascination. All these tend to produce inward subjective experiences.

And we scientifically interpret these subjective experiences in terms of the opening of the petals, the nine petals of the egoic lotus. Each in three tiers. The petals of knowledge, the petals of sacrifice, and the petals of love.

And each individual has these petals opening to some extent. And the quality of subjective experience in response to outer stress is greatly governed by which petals for that individual are being opened in that life or are the target of attention in that life. And that immediately takes us into the field of the soul's purpose.

The soul's purpose. And the soul's purpose is an expression or is an attempted expression by the lotus to open up some one or other of the petals. The soul's purpose is often a very simple affair.

So simple that we overlook it or push it aside because our ego inflation has directed us in some other direction. When we are eventually aware of the soul's purpose it's too mundane. It's too simple for us to follow.

It's so simple that in fact we can't follow it because we are too complex. Our personalities are too complex. And a personality that is complex is a personality that's not rounded up.

The rounded up personality is expressive. Has nothing to be complex about. Expresses his intentions and wishes.

Is direct about things. It is the complex personality which is unintegrated. And the more simple you are, the more rounded you are in personality, expression, the closer you are to the functioning of the egoic lotus.

So this interplay between the unconscious and the conscious is a meaningful process. And it means also therefore that archetypes are meaningful. That they are the response.

The archetypal aspect conveys meaning to an outer phenomenon. We talk about a drive expressing itself. A drive expressing itself arising as it does from the dead and infused with libidinous energy.

And as the drive expresses itself in the field of the ego there must be a compensatory archetypal mechanism showing itself. The archetypal response. So that's all we have been talking about here.

There are followed out of this other important implications. If the outer organic systems are self-regulating, if our physical body, which forms part of the ego, is self-regulating, has homeostatic mechanisms, will balance acid with alkali, heat with cold, then the inner mechanisms are also seeking an inner homeostasis. It must be true of the unconscious as well.

For the unconscious compensates. And if homeostasis is achieved in the physical body or in the personality, then there will be attempts to compensate in this direction inwardly. So he said the psyche is a self-regulating system.

Talking about the psyche of man, here it is. The psyche is a self-regulating system just as its ego is in its physical body. A self-regulating system that maintains its equilibrium just as the body does.

Every process that goes too far immediately and inevitably calls for compensations. And without these there would be neither a normal metabolism nor a normal psyche. There would be neither a normal metabolism nor a normal psyche.

Too little on one side results in too much on the other. And immediately those of you who have heard my diploma courses, been given the diploma courses, remember that one of the two main functions of the human monad is to achieve spiritual staying power. To achieve spiritual staying power.

With spiritual staying power, the monad is able to undertake the long passage, if you like, of movement from the heart chakra, which is our solar system, to the higher Ajna chakra, which is the system around Sirius. And so the monadic flame divine needs to be, as it were, capable of spiritual staying power. In the human body, physical staying power is dependent on the ability to maintain homeostasis, the ability to balance out the impacts of stress.

We go outside on a cold day to be able to sugar adequately to maintain body temperature, or out on a hot day to be able to sweat sufficiently to allow evaporation to occur so that the outer heat can be not too much interfering with the level of the blood temperature. And this is what we're trying to build. This is what the whole of evolution is about.

To build a spiritual structure which enables the monad to maintain this sort of staying power inwardly, spiritual staying power. Now, this is not a new thought on my part. I have expressed it very, very carefully in my last five books.

And so compensation is an attempt, according to Jung, to bring together psychic opposites. To bring together psychic opposites. The dream is an attempt to bridge or to satisfy both the psyche and the conscious.

The dream is an attempt to bridge or to satisfy both the psyche and the conscious. Now, that's the summing up of everything that we've had to say today. The dream is an attempt to bridge or to satisfy both the unconscious, which is the psyche, and the conscious, which is the ego.

And where this compensation doesn't work, there will be trouble. So, going now to our archetypal patterns, as they are represented in mythology, we talk about the Janus-faced individual. You will have seen in my books the myths concerning Janus, who faces two ways.

Janus, who faces two ways. We get our word January from Janus. He faces the old year and the new year, or faces Janus like the inward world and the outward world.

So, all the time, the psyche is trying to maintain homeostasis. A short while ago, we weren't aware at all of why we were dreaming, or what our subconscious or unconscious experiences were all about. Now, we do know that just as the body will balance itself between heat and cold, so too this great psyche of ours, mainly unconscious, is attempting to balance itself.

Balance itself through the elements of a dream, the elements of the dream, as opposed to the existential situation of consciousness, the existential situation in our consciousness, what we are at any particular moment. That's why the dreams are never the same. Well, they may be occasionally the same, but the dream is constantly differing, because the existential state of the consciousness outwardly is different.

We're never the same, two seconds running. Our consciousness is constantly changing, our conscious convictions and tendencies. The elements of the dream were constituent factors of the unconscious, as well as the compensations of the momentary status or existential situation of the consciousness, with which they were linked together associatively and selected by the conscious situation of the moment.

So if you want to go straight to the books of Jung, there's an example of it. I'll read it again for you. The elements of the dream were constituent factors of the unconscious, as well as compensations of the momentary status of the consciousness, with which they were linked together associatively and selected by the conscious situation of the moment.

And I don't think some of you quite appreciate how difficult some of these current psychological works are written. They are and can be extremely difficult, most of them not written for the layman at all. Most of them presuming that you have had a psychoanalytical education of some sort.

Jung found that compensation was such a basic rule that it operated with equal validity in all psychic formations. It didn't matter whether we're talking about fantasy, or whether we're talking about vision, or whether we're talking about dreams. The compensatory mechanism works for all of them.

And if you come away today with only this, it's important to understand that what we said earlier is true. All things in life are compensated for. Whether we're talking about the physical body, whether it's the astral, the mental, the manasic, the buddhic, the atmic, or even the monadic itself.

There is compensation for everything. We'll end there.