Reincarnation - How, Where & Why We Have Lived Before, Part 2 of 2
In my first lecture, I posed five questions which man eternally seeks the answers for. Who are we here on earth? Where do we come from here on earth? Where do we go to from here? Why are we here at all? And why do we have to suffer pain? I'm going to consider the question of why we are here. It is answered very clearly in these lines.
The Lord let the house of a brute to the soul of a man. And the man said, am I your debtor? The Lord said, not yet, but make it as clean as you can. And then I'll let you a better.
Henry Ford was also obsessed with this particular question. Why are we here? He said in 1938, when I was a young man, like so many others, I was bewildered. I found myself asking the question, what are we here for? I found no answer.
Without some answer to that question, life is empty and useless. Then someone handed him a book on reincarnation. After reading it, Henry Ford said, it changed my whole life.
From emptiness and uselessness, it changed my outlook on life to purpose and meaning. I believe that we are here now and we'll come back again. Of this I'm sure, that we are here for a purpose, that we go on.
Mind and memory, they are the eternals. Earlier, Henry Ford had said, I adopted the theory of reincarnation when I was 26. Religion offered nothing to the point.
Even work could not give me complete satisfaction. Even work seemed futile if we cannot utilize the experience we collect in one life in the next life. When I discovered reincarnation, it was as if I had found a universal plan.
I realized there was a chance to work out my own ideas. Time was no longer limited. I was no longer a slave to the hands of the clock.
Genius is experienced. Some seem to think that it is a gift or a talent, but it is the fruit of long experience over many lives. Some are older souls than others and so they know more.
On discovering reincarnation, Henry Ford said of it, it put my mind at ease. If you preserve a record of this conversation, write it so that it puts men's minds at ease. I would like to communicate to others the calmness that the long view of life, that reincarnation, gives to us.
Then of course there was Lloyd George, the British Prime Minister, who said, my opinion is that we shall be reincarnated. And that hereafter we shall suffer or benefit in accordance with what we have done in this world. For example, the employer who sweats his work people will be condemned to be sweated himself.
The belief in reincarnation is not like the spread of a religion. There are no evangelists for it. No teachers spreading the word like a Buddha or a Christ did.
The spread of the belief in reincarnation seems to result from the welling up in people of an intuitive feeling about it. As Schopenhauer said, it presents itself as a natural conviction of man whenever he reflects at all in any unprejudiced manner on the nature of life and death. Elizabeth Kubler-Ross, the famous research worker and author of the book, Death and Dying, read by millions of nurses and doctors said, there are many lives we have to live through in order to learn all the lessons.
Now personally, for all my own certainty of immortality, I like to think that I march and step with such death-defying reincarnationists as Thomas Edison, Aristotle, Albert Schweitzer, Leo Che, Ralph Waldo Emerson. For me, reincarnation is a cosmic catechism. It is a dialogue between man and nature.
Reincarnation opposes the idea that the origin of life is an improbable chemical accident, a fortuitous bringing together of amino acids or the chance emergence of protoplasm. At its most nebulous, it suggests that a great being is thinking out a divine scheme and that we in all other forms are part of his thought substance. There is in ancient Hindu traditions, the description of such a divine scheme as it represents the output of a great being.
There, you will find a description of it in Parabrahman. And the description describes, as it were, all the ranges of concretion of this divine thought in the mind of the Logos. From Purusha, which is almost pure spirit, right down to Mula Prakriti or root substance, the root substance underlying matter.
For me, reincarnation suggests a captain to our ships. A great sage observed that the easiest way to deal with the soul is to deny it. And we find everywhere people today denying the existence of the soul.
We cannot blame them. Their experiences of entrenched or orthodox religions have not encouraged them. The same sage said, can we suppose that a ship might be constructed of such a kind that entirely by itself without a captain or crew, it could sail from place to place, from year to year accommodating itself to varying winds, avoiding shoals, seeking a haven when necessary and doing all that a normal ship can without a captain or a navigator.
The man who denies the existence of his own higher self or his soul maintains just this proposition. Another lovely quotation comes from the writings of the poet Francis Thompson, himself a great mystic. It is the hound of heaven.
And it describes how man tends to flee from his own soul, denying it at times, often fearful of its imminence. I fled him down the nights and down the days. I fled him down the arches of the years.
I fled him down the labyrinthine ways of mine own mind. And in the midst of tears, I hid from him and under running laughter, up vistaed hopes I sped and shot, precipitated, adown Titanic glooms of chasmed fears from those strong feet that followed, followed after.[1] But with unhurrying chase and unperturbed pace, deliberate speed, majestic instancy, they beat and a voice beat more instant than the feet.
All things betray thee who betrayest me. Lovely words, describing the highest self as being a hound of heaven ever at our heels. Then there is the matter of memory of previous lives.
Those who oppose reincarnation often say that we should remember all of our lives. And if we don't, then they probably don't exist at all. We don't remember the first part of our present life, but that doesn't mean to say that we're not alive.
We don't remember much of our sleep state, but it doesn't mean to say that we're not alive. It is the proposition of the esoteric sciences that given certain disciplines and the establishment of a dialogue with a higher self, previous lives can be recalled. We don't need hypnosis for it.
We don't need psychedelic drugs for it, but we do need inner peace and serenity for this act of recalling, recalling of previous lives to be successful. There is so much insincerity about the doctrine of rebirth. Most people are being insincere when they say they can't be bothered considering a matter like reincarnation.
Is there really a person alive who has not thought of what it would like to be to go to sleep and never wake up again? Is there a person alive who has not thought, who was I before my father and my mother conceived me? Everyone, sometime or the other, considers just these matters, but many people refuse to be confronted with the harsh realities of the answer to these questions in the form of a doctrine like reincarnation. We don't ask that children should be taught reincarnation at school, but teaching them about death should be reconsidered. Why teach them about death as being semifinal, as it were, if not actually final, and not talk to them about the principles of reincarnation at the same time? I always find it interesting that as far back as a child can think, it is known only life.
The child does not remember death. It only remembers life. We have literally to teach children that death exists, and of course we do it, and do it very efficiently, even though we haven't proof that death has any sort of finality.
Is it not a terrible consideration to think that we may possibly be teaching every child something that is wrong? We even have to teach children about sorrow. So often when they are young, they're confronted with perhaps a dead sparrow and will ask a perfectly straight question without any emotion about what it was doing there. We have to inject the idea of sorrow into the matter of death.
And of course the child then takes it up and uses it for the rest of his days. I know how difficult I found it to cry at my own mother's death at the age of 14, but I soon learned how to do it from the attending mourners, my other relatives. Then there's the matter of loss of identity.
Many people become uneasy when they think of the loss of their personality, fearing in the process a loss of identity. As Ralph Waldo Emerson observed, Mr. Quinn thinks that to affirm the eternity of God is not to affirm the reappearance of Mr. Quinn, bodily and mentally, with all the appearances and recollections of Mr. Quinn. But Mr. Quinn is a sick God.
He merely thinks that in accepting the concept of reincarnation, he is going to have to give up the whole ship. In the same way, many fear that sinking one's identity into the divine in what we call nirvana is upsetting. My own opinion is that we should never fear so much of the loss of something, but look more happily upon the gain of much more, which is my own experience of treading the lighted way.
I have heard many cases suggestive of reincarnation, and I have a few that are my own favorites. Some of these I have participated in personally. Others I have had from hearsay.
Some I have read about. The first one I want to give you is the case of a little girl. On tour in Rhodesia in the year 1958, I had given a lecture on reincarnation.
The lady in the audience asked if she could see me the next day for a consultation. At that consultation, she told me about an event that had occurred 10 years earlier. She had had a daughter who died before she was four years of age.
It had greatly upset both the parents so that she didn't often talk about the child. Then a second daughter was born, and they were just delighted about it all. When the girl was about the same age as the other one when she died, the mother was bathing her one day and sang to her as was usual.
The little girl suddenly interrupted her mother and asked her to sing a song that she used to sing. The mother was puzzled and asked the child to tell her what that song was and how it went. The child began to sing.
♪ The yellow rose of Texas, the yellow rose for me. ♪ The mother froze. She had sung that same song to the child who had died.
The song was her favorite and the favorite of the child as well. And she could not bring herself to sing it to the second child after she was born. The memories that had evoked were too painful for her.
Somehow or the other, the second child had known about that song. It was the mother's belief that she was the reincarnation of that little girl. I will comment upon such matters in later talks if not in this one.
Then there was the matter of Dr. Raymond Jones and Sheila. Raymond Jones was a friend of mine. He was an ear surgeon at Baragwanath Hospital.
And he heard one of my lectures in Johannesburg and came up to me after the lecture and asked me whether I would be interested in attending a materialization seance, which was currently being held regularly in Johannesburg. He assured me that it was very valid and that many of his medical friends attended it. And if I wished to observe it purely for myself, purely dispassionately or investigated from an interest that is scientific, I would find it very useful.
I agreed. The background to the Raymond Joneses was this. Ray Jones and his wife, Sheila, had some time previously been on holiday in Northern Natal.
They had gone to, I believe it was St. Lucia Bay, with their only son, only child, a son, a boy, a boy of about 10. He was with a friend of his of the same age. One day whilst they were preparing a picnic lunch, the two boys went off together and walked along the edge of the lagoon at St. Lucia.
There they met a crocodile and the crocodile took their son and he was, of course, drowned. The event was very shocking to the family. Dr. Raymond Jones himself was deeply upset, but he was very concerned about his wife, Sheila.
Sheila was threatening suicide. And in desperation, Raymond Jones took her to the séance. Sheila, in fact, was in her forties and the chance of her conceiving again was very remote.
However, so convincing were these materializations that Sheila was certain at last that there was life after death and that her son had survived the grave. The couple hoped against hope that it might be possible for the boy to materialize as part of one of the séances. And indeed, when I met them some years later, they said that there had been such a materialization.
They weren't absolutely convinced that the materialized boy was their own son, but by that time they had weathered the terrible disaster of this tragedy. The happy note that I must end this story on is that Mrs. Raymond Jones did conceive again. Today they have a lovely boy, a son, and he is now grown up.
Then there is another story on reincarnation, which I regard as very illuminating. One day in Santa Barbara in California, a man by the name of Roberts came to a trained clairvoyant, who was also a lecturer in theosophy and asked for help in a perplexing case. Mr. Roberts had been walking in the street the previous day when a little three-year-old girl came up to him and put her arms around his knees and called him Papa.
Mr. Roberts was indignant, thinking that someone was trying to father the child on him. But the mother of the child, who came up directly, was equally put out and tried to get the child away. The child, however, kept on clinging to Mr. Roberts, insisting that he was her father.
And on account of the circumstances to be told later, Mr. Roberts could not put it out of his mind and sought out the clairvoyant, who accompanied him to the house of the child's parents, where the little girl at once ran up to him again and again called him Papa. The clairvoyant, whom I will call X, first took the child over to the window. He did this to note whether the iris of the eye would expand and contract when he turned her to and from the light in order to see whether another entity than the rightful owner was in possession of the child's body.
For the eye is the window of the soul and no obsessing entity can secure control of that part. Mr. X found, however, that the child was normal and next proceeded to question the little one carefully. After patient work carried on intermittently during the afternoon so as not to tire the child, this is the story that she told.
She had lived with her papa, Mr. Roberts, and another mama in a little house that stood alone where no other house could be seen. There was a little brook close to the house where some flowers grew. And here she ran out and brought in some pussy willows.
And there was a plank across the brook for which she was cautioned against crossing for fear she might fall into the brook. One day her papa left her mother and herself and had not returned. When their supply of food was exhausted, her mama laid down on the bed and became so still.
At last she quaintly said, then I also died, but I didn't die, I came here. Mr. Roberts next told his story. 18 years before, he had lived in London where his father was a brewer.
He fell in love with their servant girl. His father objected, so he eloped with her to Australia after they had first been married. Here he went out into the bush and cleared a little farm where he erected a small cabin by a brook just ascribed by the little girl.
A daughter was born to them there. And when she was about two years old, he left the house one morning and went to a clearing some distance away. And while there, a man with a rifle came up to him saying that he arrested him in the name of the law for a bank robbery committed on the night that Mr. Roberts had left England.
The officer had trapped him there thinking him the criminal. Mr. Roberts begged to be allowed to go to his wife and child, but thinking this as a ruse to entrap him in the hands of Confederates, the officer refused and drove him to the coast at the point of a gun. He was taken to England and tried and his innocence was proved.
First then did the authorities take heed of his constant ravings about his wife and child, whom he knew must starve in that wild and lonely country. An expedition was sent out to the cabin when it was found that only the skeletons of the wife and child remained. Mr. Roberts's father died in the meantime.
And although he had disinherited Mr. Roberts, his brothers divided with him and he came to America a broken man. He then produced photographs of himself and his wife. And at the suggestion of Mr. X, they were mixed with a number of other photographs and shown to the little girl, who unhesitatingly picked out the photographs of both her alleged parents.
Although the photograph shown was very different from the present appearance of Mr. Roberts. There are many fascinating reincarnation accounts concerning the way in which scars and moles and birthmarks seem to be carried forward from one life to another. I know in my own case, I had a mole on my chin up until the age of about 35.
It began to regress, however, and disappeared. Although I'm quite sure that parts of it might still be located there. This mole was placed in exactly the same position as a mole that was on the face of an incarnation that I had about 250 years ago.
There are a group of reincarnation cases that center around the wound that caused the death. It is suggested that where an injury produced the death, the mark of the injury is transferred in some cases to the next life. I'm going to quote from the book by Dr. Stevenson, 20 Cases Suggestive of Reincarnation.
And the case I'm quoting here is from the Tlingit Indians of Alaska. The Tlingit Indians are settled in the southeastern part of Alaska. And they're believed to have migrated from Asia thousands of years ago across the Bering Straits.
They believe in reincarnation still, and therefore are on the watch for any evidence of rebirth. Specifically, they believe that dead persons return to this world, but only among their relatives. If a pregnant woman sees in her dreams a deceased relative frequently, she believes that that relative has reentered her existence through her fetus, and will often give the child the name of the deceased ancestor.
The belief then was that if a person with a cut or a scar on his body died and was reborn, the same mark could be seen on the infant. The effect of their belief in reincarnation was strong amongst their warriors, whose fierceness was accounted for by their lack of fear of death. They not only did not fear death, but expected to return to the world in a better position.
The Tlingits also believe that a child who remembered his previous life is fated to die young, and they therefore deliberately discourage the child from remembering the previous life. Amongst these Tlingit Indians, there was a man called Charles Porter. When he was a small boy, Charles Porter used to say that he had been killed in his previous life by a spear in a clan fight amongst the Tlingit Indians.
He even named the man who had killed him. He named the place where he had been killed, and he gave his Tlingit name in the previous life. His previous life apparently was that of his mother's uncle.
When telling the story, he would point to his right side. He was examined by Dr. Ian Stevenson, who found a large, unusually shaped pigmented area in his right flank, located in the area just below the lowest rib on the right side. It was roughly diamond-shaped, measuring an inch wide and one and a half inches long.
It definitely resembled the size and shape of an old scar that a spear might make. Where the spear entered, the liver would have been transfixed and large blood vessels severed, so that death would have been almost instantaneous. Here I would insert a note to say that the Tlingit spear blades were the same shape as the mark of the scar.
Mr. Porter was a full-blooded Tlingit, but his family had been one of the first to become educated in English. He himself did not learn the Tlingit language until he was 12, and does not believe that he was told about the clan fight or any rebirth possibilities. Mr. Porter's older sister maintains that her brother began at the age of two to say that he had been killed in a previous life by a spear, and that he had even named the man who had killed him, but that he stopped talking about the event after about the age of eight.
His sister said that the child had a birthmark in this position when he was born. His mother confirmed that the boy had even been, had even named the man who had killed him, and indeed the old man was still alive at the time. Another relative interviewed said that the child had greatly feared knives, bayonets, and spears, and would go at great lengths to avoid the sight of them.
Investigation into the history of the tribes of the area showed that massacres and clan fighting had been going on until the year 1881. The man who had been speared had been born in 1845, and could easily have participated in these clan clashes that had been recorded. Dr. Stevenson carefully investigated the various facts of this case before deciding to include it in the 20 making up his famous book.
He concluded that the child could not possibly have had this information planted in him at such an early age, and there was no doubt about the shape of the birthmark exactly fitting the pattern of the usual tapered blade of the Tlingit spear. During my recent lecture tours of North America, I frequently quoted from the following article to emphasize that very good evidence does exist for belief in reincarnation. The author, Morris de Kooner, was a police official in Northern India.
The story is reproduced here from Maclean's, the Canadian magazine. I met Morris de Kooner and talked to him about the salient features of this extraordinary case. In India, violent encounters between families, caste groups, and even whole communities can flare up so swiftly, and for such a variety of reasons, often trivial, that a police officer soon learns to stop the quarrel first and ask questions afterwards.
Uttar Pradesh. I received a report of trouble brewing between two castes at a place called Sirsaganj. I took off by jeep without waiting to learn the details.
In the police station, the local inspector gave me the brief details of a fantastic situation. A five-year-old boy was being claimed by two communities. To a family of the Agarwal caste in Sirsaganj, he was Rajiv, the youngest son.
To a family of the Kachi caste in Dolatanj, he was the reincarnation of a 40-year-old man named Sumasingh, who had died five years before. What gave the Kachis the incredible idea, I asked. Rajiv himself, for nearly three years, he had been insisting he is Sumasingh.
This talk had reached the Kachis, and there could be trouble if they came here and attempted to take him back to Dolatanj. I sent for the boy and his parents. He soon arrived, accompanied by his uncle and a couple of neighbors.
His father was away, so his mother had sent her brother along, because women in India don't usually go anywhere unaccompanied by their husbands. Rajiv turned out to be a small, nervous child with large, intelligent brown eyes. To set him at ease, I gave him a banana and some candy, and he reacted as one might expect any five-year-old to.
Meanwhile, I decided to get as much of the story as I could from his uncle, Mahesh, a man in his middle 20s, neatly dressed as befitted his caste. The Agarwals are a sub-caste of the Baniyas, who are merchants and shopkeepers, and usually well-to-do. This particular family owned several grocery and cloth shops in Sirsaganj.
Mahesh was a little apprehensive, because as I learned later, he thought I'd come to take the boy away from the family. I asked him to tell me the whole story, and he told me that when Rajiv was little over two years old he was seen one day running down the road towards the north, an older boy caught him and brought him back. When his mother asked him where he was going, he said he was going home.
But Rajiv, his mother said, this is your home. No, replied the child, I'm going to my own home. And where is that, he was asked.
In the village of Dolatanj. This incident was passed off as a childish whim until it happened again a few days later. Then it happened a third time, and the boy's mother, to humor him, began asking him questions about this own home of his.
The child seemed very positive in his answers. He said his name was Sumasingh, and he lived in Dolatanj. He had five acres of land and had built his own home in the village.
He had a wife and one daughter, Ramkali, whom he had married to a boy from a nearby village of Barakala. They had had two children. He continued his attempts to go home.
They became a little worried. They consulted the family pandit, who for a fee recited a few mantras and told them not to worry. The child, however, persisted in his attempts to go home and seemed to answer quite rationally all questions put to him.
He also appeared to have considerable knowledge of adult matters, including particular caste customs of the Karchis, with whom, being a member of a higher caste now, he had never come into contact. The boy's story was checked. By the time the boy was four, the story had spread all around the neighborhood, and the people would come every day to see the child and ask him questions.
His answers were so consistent and so positive that many learned men in the area began to believe that the boy actually was remembering his previous life. Friends of the family formed a committee to check on the boy's story. First, the elders learned there actually was a village named Dolatanj, about 40 miles to the north where a community of Karchis lived.
Members of the community visited this village. They found that the statements made by the child were correct in every detail. The contents of the house and the names and the ages of all the members of the household of Sumasingh were as Rajiv had described them.
The committee looked for the little black trunk that the boy had said, I bought in Bagoan town and had my name painted on it for eight annas. They found it. Sumasingh's parents, his widow, daughter, son-in-law, and two grandchildren were all living in the house the boy had described.
The committee spoke to the village money lender from whom Sumasingh had borrowed 200 rupees many years earlier. The interest on which was still being paid by the family, though the capital had been repaid many times over. He confirmed the details of the transaction that Rajiv had described.
The village Chowkida, the constable, confirmed the story of a burned mango tree exactly as the boy had described it. Sumasingh had had a quarrel with the owner of a neighboring field. And one morning he woke up to find his mango tree burned.
He accused his neighbor of this act of vandalism. This led to another quarrel in which the two men came to blows. The matter was eventually decided by the village council.
Sumasingh's neighbor being sentenced to provide a feast for the whole village. The committee returned to Sirsaganj greatly impressed and quite convinced that young Rajiv was a reincarnation of Sumasingh. This annoyed Rajiv's parents and grandparents.
They were Agarwals and much higher in the social scale than Sumasingh's family who were Kachis. At the same time, Rajiv's family was extremely agitated lest Sumasingh's family finding the boy in well-to-do circumstances claimed him as their own. It was only when I gave Rajiv's family my assurance that my interest was purely for the purpose of preventing any possible trouble in the future that they cooperated in these inquiries.
Having got Rajiv into a good humor, I questioned him with the help of his uncle. It was like questioning any five-year-old. His attention kept wandering and many questions he just would not answer.
Sometimes a question would elicit a flood of reminiscences. I asked him how he died. I died in the government hospital in Fatigarh, he replied.
Why were you in hospital? I asked. And why so far away as Fatigarh? When our own hospital in Manipuri was very much closer. I had a bad pain in my ear, he said.
I had been treated by Dr. Sharma in the district hospital in Manipuri but it had done me no good so I was advised to try Fatigarh Hospital which is not only bigger but also has an ear, nose and throat specialist. Now this was definitely not five-year-old talk even though spoken with a decided lisp. Later I confirmed that about five years before a Dr. Sharma was the medical officer in charge of the district hospital at Manipuri and that cases that required the attention of a specialist were referred to the Fatigarh General Hospital.
How long were you in hospital? I asked. 11 days, he answered without hesitation. It cost me 400 rupees including the operation.
What happened, I asked. I died on the operating table, he replied in the most matter-of-fact of ways. After that he would tell me nothing more.
His uncle said that this was the way it always was. He would answer a few questions quite well sometimes eagerly with a quantity of detail and then suddenly would withdraw into his shell and answer no more. Other duties took me back to my office.
So I deputed, I deputed a detective and sub-inspector to continue to investigate the case thoroughly and to record the statements of all the persons concerned. He took pains over this investigation and recorded the statements not only of the immediate family of the late Sumasing and Dolatanj but also of other responsible people of the village such as the Grand Sabapati, president of the village council whose duties correspond in a smaller way to those of a mayor and the Kuchalkida or village constable. I also asked the detective to question the boy several times over a period of time on the same points to see if he contradicted himself.
Finally, I asked him to arrange a meeting between Sumasing's entire family whom the boy had never met and to see what the dead boy's, I'm sorry, to see what the boy's reaction was. Who would know but a dead man? At about this time, I was promoted and in the rush of wider responsibilities forgot this case for a while. I was reminded of it at one of my crime conferences by the new superintendent of police.
The results of this investigation when I finally got them amazed me. The records of both hospitals and the statements of the nurses, ward boys and doctors corroborated in every detail young Rajiv's story of Sumasing's illness and death. These details could not possibly have been known to anyone but Sumasing himself.
Sumasing's family may have known the broader facts of the illness and treatment but they could not possibly know what happened in the operating theater, for example. Added to this, Rajiv never contradicted himself once on any point of fact. The result of the meeting between Sumasing's family and young Rajiv seemed to put the clincher on the whole story.
Rajiv's parents were most reluctant to allow such a meeting. The whole Agarwal community was up in arms. It was quite certain that Rajiv had never in his young life been outside his village.
It was equally certain that Sumasing's family had never gone beyond the town of Bagoan except when they took Sumasing to a hospital at Manipuri and Fatigarh. Curiosity and the will of the local pandit eventually persuaded Rajiv's parents to agree to this meeting on the express condition that no matter what the result, Rajiv would not be taken away from them. Sumasing's entire family was brought to Sirsaganj.
Rajiv was not told anything about this. The family was assembled in the room. Rajiv's parents, uncle, other relatives, family friends, local pandits and the detective were also present.
Rajiv was brought into the room. He looked around in surprise and then a change seemed to come over him. The change was not physical, but was in fact a complete transition of his demeanor from that of a child to a dignified adult.
He walked up to Sumasing's father slowly, but deliberately and touched his feet in India's ancient gesture of veneration. He then touched Sumasing's mother's feet and called her Mataji, mother. He then looked at Sumasing's widow who was now in her middle forties and turned his face away with a gentle smile.
When asked who the lady was, he appeared embarrassed and kept his head down. When the question was repeated, he replied with a shy smile, Ram Kali's mother. This behavior was absolutely typical of a man of Sumasing's class and circumstances.
When any reference is made to his wife and the presence of his parents, a man never discusses his wife or even acknowledges her presence in front of his parents. His wife is also not referred to by name, but as the mother of his eldest child. Sumasing's daughter, Ram Kali, now a matronly woman of about 30, was pointed to next.
Rajiv's manner changed at once. He looked up, smiled confidently and said, that's my Bitya, my little daughter. He was asked how he knew.
Look on her right forearm, he said. You'll find my name tattooed there. I had that done when she was 13, just before she was married at the fair in Bagoan.
Ram Kali's face was a picture of amazement. I saw other women being tattooed, she whispered. I was not a child anymore.
I was going to be married soon. I wanted to be tattooed. My father allowed me.
I did not know what to have tattooed. I loved my father very much. So I had his name tattooed on my right forearm.
She slowly put her bangle encased right arm out with a look of awe on her face. And there on her forearm was the tattoo, dimmed by age, but still readable. She rushed forward suddenly, knelt before young Rajiv and put her forehead on his feet, crying, Bapu, Bapu, father, quite piteously.
She then got up, grabbed her two teenage sons who were standing uncertainly near her and pulled them down at Rajiv's feet. Touch your grandfather's feet, she ordered, and meekly they obeyed. There did not seem to be any doubt, whatever in the mind of any person in that room, that Rajiv's body was indeed occupied by the debarted soul of Sumasingh.
From the hospital death certificate, it appeared that Sumasingh's death took place approximately two hours before Rajiv was born, almost a hundred miles away. After the meeting event took a happy turn, instead of the expected trouble between the two families over possession of Rajiv, there was harmony between them, due largely to the wise head on the old stooped shoulders of the late Sumasingh's father. This venerable gentleman got up and with the authority of age addressed the group.
Suma was a very good son to me, he said. He was also a good husband to my daughter-in-law and a good father to Ram Kali. He was respected in the village as an honest man.
His death was a loss, not only to my family, but to the whole village. God is, however, wonderfully wise in his ways. He knew that the doctor killed my son before his allotted years on this earth were over.
He therefore decided to send him back again to enjoy once more the innocent joys of childhood. And because Suma had lived a good, clean life, God in his wisdom decided to send him to a richer and better home. We are grateful to God, not only for sending Suma back, but for improving his condition and life.
We would be doing Suma a disfavor if we took him away now, as my wife wants us to do. We cannot give him such fine clothes or such a good home or even a good education as he now has. Keep my son, sir, he added, turning to Rajiv's father.
Only allow me in my old age sometimes to see him and to inquire about his welfare. And when my time comes to leave this earth, as it soon will, will you send my son to light my funeral pyre according to the dictates of tradition? Rajiv's father agreed to this and the meeting ended happily. Rajiv soon reverted to his own shy, childish self and to the best of my knowledge is still playing around in Sirsaganj, a normal, healthy, happy child in a good home who is perhaps not even aware of the storm that he created.
There is one more case I would like to mention. It is also from the book by Dr. Ian Stevenson. It is the case of Rajul Shah.
She was born in a village in India on the 14th of August, 1960. She started to talk at 12 months and at the age of two and a half began speaking spontaneously of a previous life wherein her name had been Geeta, that she was small when she died of a serious fever. Because of her lavish detail of the previous life, Rajul's parents decided to investigate whether Geeta had actually lived and died because of their belief that the soul must find another body immediately upon death of the old one.
They estimated that Geeta had to have died during the last half of October or the first half of November, 1959. In other words, at the time of her new body's conception. Investigation revealed that a child named Geeta had indeed died on the 28th of October, 1959 and in the town where Rajul had claimed to have lived as Geeta.
Rajul was taken to visit Geeta's family, the Thakur family and her familiarity with the house and with the details of the Thakur's life convinced them that she was indeed their dead Geeta reborn. Prior contact between the two families is the source of Rajul's information about the Thakur household was ruled out after careful checking. Specific facts cited by Rajul which were subsequently confirmed were these.
Geeta's house had two rooms and a kitchen and a veranda. The name of Geeta's mother was Kanta. Actually it was Kanta Ben.
Geeta's family were Lohanas, members of a sub-caste or a clan of merchants. Geeta's father wore dhotis unlike Rajul's father who wore pajamas. Geeta's father ate from a steel plate while others in the family ate from brass plates.
Geeta's family used to eat dinner after dark while Rajul's ate before sunset. All in all there are some 50 specific units of information including the recognition of people or places pertaining to the life of the dead Geeta which Rajul mentioned or with which she showed familiarity. This is quite a performance for a five-year-old child.
Dr. Ian Stevenson is satisfied that normal sources of information must be ruled out here. Where did Rajul get these facts? The imminence of death plays an important part in the fact that many people are drawn to consider reincarnation. It is ridiculous to say that we are not used to death and dying a thousand times.
Why we can sit around a dinner table and discuss war and the probable death by volatilization of 60 million souls through an atom bomb without being more upset than if we were discussing how bad the weather was. Every day we can watch abrupt and bloody death on television and on films without blinking back a tear. It is the experience of many physicians like myself and like the person who wrote these words, Dr. Lewis Thomas, that dying is an all right thing to do.
Most patients accept death serenely and without fear. Most appear to be preparing themselves for it as though they are intuitively familiar with the whole business so that we think that death is a natural matter. Equally so, we feel that rebirth or reincarnation is an intuitive feeling, which is had by countless peoples living in remote quarters of the globe.
As Schopenhauer, the great philosopher said, it presents itself as a natural conviction of man whenever he reflects at all in an unprejudiced manner. Then there are, of course, the skeptics. The problem with people who are skeptics becomes fairly plain.
We can all accept a little honest doubt, and doubt can be the beginning of wisdom, but skepticism is a different matter. Emerson said of skepticism, it is slow suicide. The halls of science are filled with skeptics and I've certainly met my fair share of them giving more than 10,000 lectures publicly in the last 25 years.
One difficulty that skeptics face is that they have a problem accepting that life is cyclic. Whereas the scientists themselves have observed vast varieties of periodicities and have recorded them carefully, we ourselves live out each day dictated by circadian rhythm itself. The years reflect the seasons.
The ages of activity are replaced with equal periods of pralaya. What other examples are there of the cycles which constitute life? The poets are always singing of life's ceaseless pulsations, of the in-breathing and the out-breathing of worlds, of the ebb and flow of seas, of water rising as vapor to heaven and descending again as rain, of winter's death eternally followed by spring. I would say it is very strange, very strange indeed, if man's own life processes are not an exception to this rule.
The 19th century historian H.T. Buckle declared, if immortality is untrue, it doesn't matter whether anything else is true or not. Long before I myself heard of reincarnation, I had to live through the war years without it, faced with death every day around me. I had only the belief that my mind and emotions and my vitality would soon disappear like a puff of smoke.
Thus said Edmund Wilson. It had, he said, the effect useful at the time of making earthly affairs seem unimportant and human beings more and more ignoble. It made it hard for me to take human life seriously or indeed my own efforts and achievements with any seriousness.
It coarsened me. And at the time, during the war, it served its purpose. Later, on the other hand, belief in reincarnation had for me the very opposite effect.
Shelley, the poet, detested materialists and with them, the skeptics. He wrote a lovely poem called Ozymandias about them. I met a traveler from an antique land who said, two vast and trunkless legs of stone stand in the desert.
Near them, on the sand, half sunk, a shattered visage lies, whose frown and wrinkled lip and sneer of cold command tell that its sculptor well those passions read which yet survive stamped on these lifeless things, the hand that mocked them and the heart that fed. And on the pedestal, these words appear. My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings.
Look on my works, ye mighty, and despair. Nothing beside remains. Round the decay of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare, the lone and level sands stretch far away.[2]
