Atlantis I
Most of us in the West have grown up with the idea of Atlantis, to which has been added the concepts of Theosophy and other explorative traditions. The first criticism the well-informed mind has to make about the subject is that we are at a loss to measure the age of Atlantis in terms of any civilisations or other assessments in terms of time and space.
For instance, we grow up being taught the dimensions of spacetime[1] in terms of the Bronze Age, the Iron Age, and so on. When we explore more deeply, we find that the Iron Age — far from being an age determined by a timescale or global area maps — is really a figment of the imagination, when the truth lies in the fact that iron and its usage did not obey the general laws that we apply to large concepts in spacetime. Its usage was widespread even in areas as yet unknown and where time records were not kept.
Iron is an important consideration if we are going to fathom the where, when and how of Atlantis. The general idea of Atlantis is of a large continent-island in the mid-Atlantic lying north of the Equator. It therefore suggests a maritime state, with colonies and appropriate shipping to allow for trade and communication between the mother state and her colonies.
Some of these colonies were supposed to have existed in what we now call Egypt and in what we now call Central America — words like Aztec and Mayan come to mind — and the only proof of such empire-like organisations are in the architecture they left behind. The pyramid is the structure that seems to suggest a central originating factor linking Atlantis to its colonies. The most governing factor therefore in our researches on Atlantis is the nature of the sea on which it developed.
The Atlantic Ocean is nothing like the Pacific or even the Indian Ocean. The Atlantic is swept by gales as well as trade winds and other well-known disturbances of wind and the element of air. It is not uncommon for ocean liners having crossed the Atlantic to reach port battered and bent by sixty-foot waves that have arisen in huge Atlantic storms. Any traveller of foreign lands knows the record of Atlantic storms and how they have determined the structure, shape and texture that ships ploughing the Atlantic must incorporate in order to survive its violent temperament.
If we look at the ships of other ancient civilisations, they were comfortably made out of various kinds of wood, palms and reeds, bound or glued together in whatever fashion the particular civilisation was able to devise: Chinese boats for their huge rivers often in flood; boats that plied the waters of the Tigris and Euphrates, the Nile and the Mediterranean itself; to say nothing of the Polynesian islands of the greater Pacific expanses — all had their idiosyncrasies, and their boats were adapted accordingly. But whether we look at the Vikings, who could have reached Atlantis from their Nordic homes, or the Phoenicians plying the Mediterranean even beyond the Pillars of Hercules,[2] there is never any suggestion that the iron vessels that would be required to survive Atlantic storms were ever built until the Industrial Revolution only a few centuries ago.
When we study the explorations of the Portuguese alone, who were masters of navigation, we find them rounding the Cape of Good Hope in seriously limited vessels which could never ply the Atlantic regularly. Even Columbus, and the vessels that regularly crossed the Atlantic after 1492, were tiny and fragile for such venturesome sea trips and had to make their journeys with a fleet of small ships which could not carry collectively anything like the cargoes of our modern liners.
The oceans and the seas often stimulate — and even originate — flows of mythological truths. Who knows whether the great myths of Atlantis and Troy were valid, part-truth, or totally fictitious. It is better to leave them as they are, perhaps posing all three roles even in modern times, to the minds of those who now sit tirelessly expending their creative energies on computers. Ships have always been the bearers of such legends to land-bound men, as they were to the author of Shakespeare's plays.[3]
The Old Ships
I have seen old ships sail like swans asleep
Beyond the village which men still call Tyre,
With leaden age o'ercargoed, dipping deep
For Famagusta and the hidden sun
That rings black Cyprus with a lake of fire;
And all those ships were certainly so old —
Who knows how oft with squat and noisy gun,
Questing brown slaves or Syrian oranges,
The pirate Genoese
Hell-raked them till they rolled
Blood, water, fruit and corpses up the hold.
But now through friendly seas they softly run,
Painted the mid-sea blue or shore-sea green,
Still patterned with the vine and grapes in gold.
But I have seen,
Pointing her shapely shadows from the dawn
And image tumbled on a rose-swept bay,
A drowsy ship of some yet older day;
And, wonder's breath indrawn,
Thought I — who knows — who knows — but in that same
(Fished up beyond Aeaea, patched up new
— Stern painted brighter blue —)
That talkative, bald-headed seaman came
(Twelve patient comrades sweating at the oar)
From Troy's doom-crimson shore,
And with great lies about his wooden horse
Set the crew laughing, and forgot his course.
It was so old a ship — who knows, who knows?
— And yet so beautiful, I watched in vain
To see the mast burst open with a rose,
And the whole deck put on its leaves again.
— James Elroy Flecker[4]
Had Vasco da Gama,[5] in his voyage around the Cape to India, landed an explorative party on the beaches of South-Eastern Africa opposite the country now called Swaziland, they might have discovered the remains of ancient earthworks where iron had been wrought out of the earth and carried northwards in Arab dhows[6] up the East Coast of Africa to the Middle East for employment there.
Iron was discovered and used in different places in different parts of the world at different times. It does not appear to have been used, however, by the civilisation we call Atlantis — who would have needed at least iron devices like nails and bolts to hold their wooden ships sturdily together, to say nothing of what would be needed to construct iron ships suitable for weathering Atlantic storms.
Iron asteroids have hit the Earth for billions of years — I have examined some myself. It is inconceivable that a civilisation as advanced as the supposed Atlantis would not have smelted the iron materials that, reinforced with concrete, might have provided high alternatives to the pyramids, and large ships to plough the Atlantic fearlessly.
The concept of Atlantis mainly continues to survive because it is said that Plato[7] brought news of it from Egypt, where information concerning Atlantis had been given out by initiates. Plato spoke of a civilisation that lay beyond the Pillars of Hercules — what we now call the Straits of Gibraltar — which is due west of Greece, where Plato led his Academy. It may well be that he was talking of small island civilisations that lay just beyond the straits.
Then there is the matter of evidence of Atlantean structures on the sea bed of the Atlantic Ocean. We not only cannot find any evidence of ships that regularly plied the Atlantic, but there is no evidence that any part of the floor of the Atlantic had been tampered with on any large scale.
The whole floor of the Atlantic has been carefully studied; its magnetic fields have been measured accurately, and there is no suggestion of the collapse of a sub-continent ten thousand years ago. When you dredge up some of the sea bed and examine it very carefully, there is no evidence that any of it was in contact with atmospheric oxygen and the gases of the atmosphere as early as ten thousand years ago. Even if you examine the Canary Islands or the Azores and consider the evidence that they might have been the tops of mountains on the island of Atlantis, you find that these mountains have been pushed up by volcanoes and their age does not fit with concepts of Atlantis.
Then there is the matter of the pyramids and their cultural artefacts. They look very fine, as do the ziggurats[8] of Babylon. All were built in their characteristic shape because there was no such thing as reinforced concrete at that time, which of course would have required iron.
The Tower of Babel, history tells us, fell many times; it was built of bricks from mud and clay, and its structure could not rise any higher and had to taper off as it did. So when you look at the mechanics behind the legends of Atlantis, you don't come up with very convincing evidence for its existence as described in popular tradition.[9]
Transcribed by A.H., 23 August 2008 — Claregate College student
Dr. Baker uses 'spacetime' in its broadest sense here, encompassing both geographical extent and historical period. ↑
The Pillars of Hercules: the ancient name for the Strait of Gibraltar, the narrow passage connecting the Atlantic Ocean and the Mediterranean Sea, considered by the ancient world to mark the edge of the known world. ↑
Dr. Baker alludes here to the long-standing theory that Francis Bacon or another figure was the true author of Shakespeare's works — a subject he addressed elsewhere in his esoteric writings. ↑
James Elroy Flecker (1884–1915), English poet; 'The Old Ships' was published in Georgian Poetry, 1913–1915. ↑
Vasco da Gama (c.1460–1524), Portuguese explorer who completed the first sea voyage from Europe to India by rounding the Cape of Good Hope (1497–1499). ↑
A dhow is a traditional Arab sailing vessel, commonly used for coastal and ocean trade along the East African and Indian Ocean routes. ↑
Plato (c.428–348 BC), Greek philosopher and founder of the Academy in Athens; his dialogues Timaeus and Critias contain the earliest surviving written accounts of Atlantis. ↑
A ziggurat is a massive stepped temple-tower of ancient Mesopotamia, found in Babylon and Sumeria; the Tower of Babel is believed by some to have been a ziggurat. ↑
Dr. Baker's original text, as transcribed, ends mid-sentence at 'you don't come up with very convincing evidence for its existence...'. The words 'as described in popular tradition' were added by an earlier editorial pass, offered here as a possible ending to complete the thought — not Dr. Baker's own words. ↑
