unpublished · Consciousness

The Moral Landscape Notes

Notes on The Moral Landscape by Sam Harris (2010)

Editorial note: Dr. Baker’s notes use the abbreviations ‘CA’ and ‘PA’ throughout without explanation in the original; based on their pattern of use, they most plausibly stand for something like ‘Critical Analysis’ (points of critique) and ‘Positive Analysis’ (points of agreement), though this reading is an editorial inference, not stated by Dr. Baker.[1]

Morals / Values can be defined in relation to the ‘well-being’ of ‘conscious’ creatures.

Neurophysiology as a scientific means to establishing ‘well-being.’

CA — ‘The’ moral landscape — the definitive article suggests a singular, innate structure waiting to be uncovered rather than a rigorously, scientifically defined one.

CA — Defining well-being — health, social, cultural, personal — seems initially problematic, but the search for cross-cultural similarities seems an extremely worthwhile endeavour.

CA — ‘The neurophysiology of happiness’ — or ‘enjoyment’ — which in the case of some people could amount to socially destructive acts. Cultural relativism, personal relativism (Freudian psychology).

CA — ‘Science’ as some stand-alone meta-entity devoid of human involvement. The scientific method as a means to establishing morals within the context of particular sciences: neuroscience, chemistry etc.

PA — The scientific method explicitly minimises the relativity of disparate human opinions and, as with the Zeitgeist manifesto, could be a viable solution to social ills.

CA — P.10 — Truth with a capital ‘T.’

CA — P.10 — ‘Meanings, Values MUST relate to well-being of conscious creatures.’ Because behaviourally humans compete for resources, this version of morality does not seem to be behaviourally operational or innate; therefore it is to be defined by science in this case.

PA — Only a ‘rational’ understanding of human well-being will allow humans to co-exist globally.

‘Human experience shows up entirely within the brain.’

‘Good supports well-being.’

  1. These are Dr. Baker’s reading notes on The Moral Landscape: How Science Can Determine Human Values by Sam Harris (2010). ↑