Communication with the Dead
The question frequently arises as to whether we should ever make contact with human beings who have died. The Theosophical attitude, which has included persons such as Annie Besant and Alice Bailey, was that this should not be attempted, because it in some way distracts the deceased from their natural evolution into the greater light.[1] I have chosen a letter from a dear friend in my native South Africa who, about a decade ago, wrote to me about the death of a loved one and her subsequent feelings of wanting to make contact with him:
Dear Professor Baker,
I obtained your address from a friend in East London who attended one of your lectures. I did, however, listen in on your radio talk as well as to your recorded lecture.
When I heard what the tape was about I was all ears and loved it. Cold shivers ran down my body. I was delighted to listen to this subject as it has and always will be my favourite one. Ever since I can recall — I am almost 60 — I have had an inclination towards anything spiritual. I have seen spirits in solid form, including my father, whose face was about 10cm from my own. I have heard things, felt things, sensed them, felt presences, etc. Also, I gave clairvoyance in church for about 9 years, so you can appreciate my interest. I feel very cut off here as nobody can appreciate my interest. I feel there are so many souls trying to contact loved ones and cannot do so. A person once asked me why I believe in this way. My answer was: why should you imagine there is a difference in an individual just because he or she has cast off their physical body? Life goes on, whether it be here or in spirit. What difference can there be? Why should we not be kept in contact with our loved ones because they are now deceased or cannot be seen?
I believe they are still close to us, even if they are high up in spirit.
My darling friend, who left in 1990, only appeared to me once. Although there is a very close affinity between us, I am hoping to meet him again.
The Theosophical View
Instead of reiterating the Theosophical attitude towards contacting those who have passed over, I have chosen the comments of a once-famous Theosophist:
Do you think one is ever justified in consulting mediums in the effort to communicate with the deceased?
I can answer this by saying that it is the teaching of the Wisdom-Religion of mankind, today called Theosophy, that any attempt to communicate with those who have passed on — by mediums or sensitives, or in any other wise — is a cruel injustice, perpetrated, alas, usually in ignorance, upon souls who are struggling to wing their way into brighter and grander spheres; and any such effort, even if only moderately successful, holds the departing spiritual essence back.
Furthermore, it is utterly impossible, by nature's grand and compassionate laws, physically to communicate with the spiritual essence of any human being; for when such spiritual essence has broken its links with the material world at death of the physical body — which is cast aside as a worn-out garment — the spiritual essence cannot ever be reached materially at all. The utmost that could be done would be a psycho-magnetic communication with the astral reliquiae, or what the consensus of mankind has called the 'spook' or 'bhuta'.
Please understand that this answer to your question is in no wise intended to be a slur upon the many splendid and kindly people who belong to the so-called Spiritualistic ranks. I would not hurt their feelings for anything, and yet I am duty bound, as a Theosophist Teacher, when a question is asked of me, to tell honestly and without reserve what the teachings of the Wisdom-Religion of mankind are.
I may add this as a comment to what I have just written: there is, nevertheless, a sublime way of coming into heart-touch with those whom we have loved and who have passed on, and that is through our own spiritual nature — in other words, by raising our hearts in impersonal love towards the memory, the blessed memory, of those whom we have loved, and who are no longer physically with us.
There is a real spiritual companionship — an actual one — if those left behind in the physical body can be so impersonal and loving of heart that they can do this. The spirit is universal in its reaches, and love overleaps all boundaries, either of space or time; and thus even the living on earth can come into loving spiritual touch with the ones who are freed.
But any attempt to do this through mediums, or through psychics or sensitives, etc., I feel in duty bound to tell you is not only an unfortunate misjudgement but deleterious to the spiritual health of both the medium and the one who so tries. Alas that there should be such ignorance of Nature's great laws among people who are otherwise, in so many cases, devoted, kindly, splendid people.
— G. de Purucker, Studies in Occult Philosophy[2]
Annie Besant (1847–1933) was a prominent Theosophist, social reformer, and President of the Theosophical Society. Alice Bailey (1880–1949) was a writer of esoteric philosophy and a key figure in the development of the Ancient Wisdom tradition. Both are central influences in Dr. Baker's work. ↑
Gottfried de Purucker (1874–1942) was an American-born Theosophist (born in Suffern, New York) and Leader of the Theosophical Society (Point Loma) from 1929 until his death in 1942. Studies in Occult Philosophy is one of his major works, exploring the deeper metaphysical teachings of the Ancient Wisdom tradition. Verified via web search, 2026-08-08. ↑
