unpublished · Esoteric Healing

The Psychoses of Plato

The Psychoses of Plato

We are used to referring to the ‘cave scene’ described by Plato that compares life on earth to being shackled before a cave wall and the heaven state to the sunlit surface above. It then comes as a shock to find, on examining orthodox medicine’s views, that Plato’s description of the divine realms is tantamount to insanity or psychosis[1].

Psychosis:

A severe mental disorder in which the individual loses contact with reality. Psychosis contrasts with neurosis[2], which describes the milder group of mental illnesses. Neurotic individuals generally know they are ill, but psychotic illness so disturbs the ability to think, perceive and judge clearly that sufferers often do not realise they are unwell. Psychosis is often what people think of as madness… the main feature of psychotic illness symptoms is that they may lead the person to view life in a distorted way. Symptoms include delusions, hallucinations, thought disorders, loss of affect (emotions), mania and depression.

— British Medical Association

The author had not long begun the study of medicine at Sheffield Medical School when he discovered the landlady of his lodgings was psychotic. She mixed me up with the manager of the local cinema and would occasionally oppose my entry into her establishment. As if that wasn’t enough she implied that the same manager (half her age) had taken a shine to her!

The good lady — let us call her Mrs T. — had serious doubts about the activities of her neighbours of forty years, whom she accused of scaling her fence to steal roses from her back garden. When I pointed out that the corrugated iron fence was seven feet high she was unabashed. Her grandson then installed an old television and I had to submit to her shrieks of laughter coming up the staircase to my flat. At first I would hopefully search my own TV for the same programme that rocked Mrs T.

Alas I found nothing approaching humour on any of the channels. I began to double lock my front door.

One day Mrs T. overheard my paying five shillings to one of the medical students for a sweepstake ticket on the Derby. He was on the front doorstep and Mrs T. rushed out to ask me for the week’s rent before I blew it all on the big race!

Plato’s Cave

The cave scenario makes for thoughtful, even provocative reading.

Read by the mystic, the Theosophist or anyone substantially into religion, the passage does not suggest insanity at all — not even the manner Plato describes in which every-day citizens are chained to the cave floor. It could however be termed a distortion of perception, one of the criterial symptoms of psychotic illness. Many a psychiatrist would raise his eyebrows at the concept and an investigating professor of comparative religion might compare it to psychedelic experience.

[An illustration of Plato’s Cave was not available to substitute for the original at this position; see Open Items Log.]

Plato’s Cave: prisoners chained before the wall of shadows, the fire behind them, and the passage to sunlight above — allegory of the Soul’s journey from illusion to reality.

  1. A severe mental disorder characterised by loss of contact with reality; see the British Medical Association definition quoted below. ↑

  2. The milder group of mental illnesses, in which the individual generally retains awareness of being ill. ↑