More on Teleology
Teleology is the doctrine that there is evidence of purpose[1] — even design — in the universe, and especially that these provide proof that there is a designer.
This has not received the support of science, which until recently thought it had carte blanche, complete discretion in such matters. But alarm bells are sounding in science’s worldwide establishments. Not only are there the inevitable attacks by fundamentalists on Darwinian principles, but loud and strident disaffection amongst prominent scientists seems to be spreading. On top of it all, politicians have joined in with support for ‘Intelligent Design’ instead of evolution by natural selection being behind the origin of man.
One would have expected a broader attitude amongst scientists when the invention of the computer was added to the equation, and even the most liberated minds began to frame questions like: if the human brain is substantially a computer, who designed it? Even worse — from where has come its software that increasingly adds quality to time and infinity to space?
Lord Winston[2] at the Cheltenham Literature Festival, October 2006
[Editor's note: The following summarises Lord Winston's remarks as reported in The Times, 11 October 2006, under the headline ‘Belief in higher power may have been the key to mankind's survival.’ Direct quotations are kept brief in accordance with copyright.]
Lord Winston argued at the Cheltenham Literature Festival that spirituality and belief in God may be the result of evolutionary pressure, and that religiosity may have a genetic basis. He suggested that in life-or-death situations, belief can be the key to survival and may therefore have become programmed into human genes.
‘I take the view, which is quite controversial among scientists, that religious values are worthwhile,’ he said, adding that prehistoric man may have been driven to monumental undertakings like building Stonehenge by ‘the search for transcendentalism.’
Winston cited research by Dean Hamer[3] — who had previously proposed the existence of a gene for homosexuality — as suggesting the existence of what Hamer called a ‘God gene,’ linked to neurotransmitters that engender feelings of wellbeing and may be related to religiosity. Winston acknowledged that even if such a gene were identified, it would not bring science closer to answering whether God exists. His conclusion: ‘Religion and science are different views of looking at uncertainty. I don't think they are opposed.’
— The Times, October 2006
But isn’t this Theosophy, pure and simple?
Alice A. Bailey made purpose the central theme of the final verse of the Great Invocation, intended to act as a carrier wave for the Ray of Will and Power streaming out of Shamballa. The Great Invocation is one of the most widely used esoteric mantrams in the Theosophical tradition, given by the Tibetan Master Djwhal Khul through Bailey and used globally in group meditation. ↑
Lord Winston (Robert Winston, b.1940), British scientist, medical doctor, television presenter and Labour life peer; Professor of Science and Society at Imperial College London; known particularly for his work in reproductive medicine and his popular science programmes (biographical details confirmed). ↑
Dean Hamer (b.1951), American geneticist at the National Cancer Institute; author of The God Gene: How Faith is Hardwired into our Genes (2004), which proposed that a specific gene (VMAT2) predisposes individuals toward spiritual experiences. The theory remains controversial within mainstream genetics (book and claims confirmed; scientific reception could not be independently re-verified beyond what is already noted here as controversial). ↑
